Are You Unknowingly Setting Your Team Up For Failure

Photo by Mathisa_s/iStock / Getty Images

Why Struggle Matters

This leadership challenge often reminds me of a story about a butterfly.

A man notices a butterfly struggling to emerge from its cocoon. Wanting to help, he carefully cuts the cocoon open, allowing the butterfly to escape more easily.

But the butterfly never flies.

What the man didn't understand was that the struggle to push through the narrow opening served a purpose. The effort forced fluid from the butterfly's body into its wings, strengthening them for flight. By removing the struggle, he unintentionally prevented the butterfly from developing what it needed most.

Whether the story is fact, folklore, or simply a powerful metaphor, the lesson is relevant for leaders.

When we rush to remove every obstacle for our employees, we may also remove opportunities for growth.

The difficult conversation, the problem that requires critical thinking, the decision that carries some risk, these are often the moments that build confidence, judgment, and capability.

As leaders, our job is not to eliminate every struggle.

Our job is to provide enough support that people can successfully work through the struggle themselves.

Then I would transition right back into the practical leadership application:

This doesn't mean leaving employees to figure everything out on their own.

It means shifting from answer-giver to thinking partner.

What I like about this approach is that it actually reinforces one of the strongest themes I see emerging in your recent writing:

Pressure doesn't create the crack. Pressure reveals where reinforcement is missing.

That's essentially the same lesson.

The butterfly doesn't develop strength because someone hands it freedom.

It develops strength because it works through the challenge.

Just like leaders.

Just like employees.

Just like organizations.

So yes, I'd keep the butterfly story. I just wouldn't let it take over the article. I'd use it as the emotional centerpiece that makes the leadership lesson memorable.

© Rachel Carey-McElwaney and www.emerginglotuscoaching.com, 2018. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Rachel Carey-McElwaney and www.emerginglotuscoaching.com with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.